Author: <span>Eric Smith</span>

History

1908: Massillon 0 Salem 18

QUAKERS
ARE TOO MUCH FOR M.H.S.
Massillon Lost to the Salem Team, Saturday.

SCORE:  SALEM  18,     MASSILLON   0
Loose Playing on the Part of the Local Team Allowed Its Opponents Three Touchdowns
Salem Played Well Together and With Spirit.

While holding its own a good share of the time and occasionally making progress forward, the Massillon high school team, by steaks of loose playing, allowed Salem high to pile up 18 points on them, on the high school grounds, Saturday afternoon.  In spite of the score the game was not altogether one-sided.  The two teams were about evenly matched.  Salem outweighed Massillon several pounds to the man but that is not what won the game.  The Salem men got together on the kickoff and stayed together throughout the game.  They played a fast game on defense.  Once in a while Massillon could get through and break up a play before it started, but on the whole the Salemites were too fast and smashed the line before Massillon had a chance to brace.  On defense Salem’s heavy line played low and all attempts at the forward pass or other tricks were watched carefully.

On the other hand Massillon’s playing was erratic. The great form which the team is capable of was not in evidence throughout the game.  Had it been, the two teams would probably have played each other to a standstill.  As it was Massillon was unable to get together. Except, at times the team work and forward pass failed to pan out in the proper proportions.  Once the forward pass was worked successfully but was called back as players were in motion on a line shift when the ball was put in play.  During the latter part of the first half and parts of the second, Massillon held her own.  Once a grand rally was made which almost carried the ball over for a score.

Working Sonnhalter on off tackle bucks continually the ball was carried straight up the field toward the goal, Massillon making her yards time and again.  When but four yards from the goal, Salem took a mighty brace and held for downs.  A punt by Salem got the ball out of danger.  Once again Massillon came within a few yards of scoring on an onside kick from the center of the field.  The ball was kicked by Heyman and went bounding along on the right side of the field.  It was missed by the Salem back and bounded backward.  Two Massillon players made attempts to secure it but Salem players at last fell on it five yards from the goal.  A delayed pass carried the ball out of danger.

Salem in general played a good game, but one player stood out of the team work and distinguished himself by his individual playing.  This was Heis, at right half back, who carried the ball for substantial gains time and again, without any interference by his clever dodging in a broken field.  He ran back punts in the same manner.  Whinnery, Salem’s fullback, although he played a good game and bucked the line in good shape, did not equal Sonnhalter in the general game.  But for Sonnhalter, who blocked up the line in the rear the game might have gone much more to the bad than it did.  Moody, who began the game at right tackle, played hard and blocked his position in good shape.  Clay, arriving in time for the second half, took Moody’s place.  As individuals little can be said against the Massillon team.  In a game like that played Saturday it is team work which counts.  Sonnhalter’s heavy line bucks were responsible for most of Massillon’s gains.  Snavely played a good game and carried back punts well.  Heyman and Erb held the left side well on defensive, while Blackburn, although he had his hands full, handled the 220 pound Lynn in good shape.  Kelly played hard at end.

A crowd numbering five hundred, including the two hundred high school students, turned out to the game and supported the home team to the last gasp.  Songs and yells stirred on the laggard spirits but it was of no avail.  Salem scored two touchdowns in the first half and one in the second.  Goals were kicked each time.

Following is the line-up:

Massillon – 0                  Pos.     Salem – 18
Kelley            le            Rogers
Erb                 lt      McConner
Heyman         lg               Lynn
Davis              c         Tollerton
Blackburn      rg           Shelton
Moody, Clay  rt              Cook
Wells             re             Karey
Atwater        qb                Nuff
Hammersmith lh         Williman
Snavely         rh                Heis
Sonnhalter     fb        Whinnery

Time of halves – 25 minutes.

Touchdowns:  Salem – Heis; Williman; Whinnery.

Goals from touchdowns:  Salem – Muff  3.

Referee – Wittmann.
Linesman – Bloomberg.
Timekeepers – Hall and Coleman.

History

1908: Massillon 64 Alliance 0

ALLIANCE MET ITS WATERLOO
Massillon High Evened Up
With a Crushing Defeat.

MASSILLON – 64;  ALLIANCE – 0
Coach Hall’s Relentless Scoring Machine Showed Great Form
A Thick and Blinding Snow Storm Added a Most Spectacular Feature to the game.

The Massillon high school, playing with almost perfect team work, aided by flashes of individual work, piled up 64 points with little trouble on the Alliance team, fighting bitterly but without spirit, Saturday afternoon on the high school grounds.  When Massillon had pushed over the last touchdown and Heyman’s great boot had brought the score to its final figure, the snow was settling over the field in blankets and feather beds.  The air was thick with enormous flakes.  Objects could not be distinguished forty yards away.  The sidelines with people wee two long grey blotches on the chaos of white.  The players were gray figures lining up and breaking in the white gloom, and on the last punt the ball could not be seen by the players who were to receive it.  As soon as Massillon again had the ball in its possession Acting Captain Snavely called the game a few minutes before the twenty minute half was up.

The arrival of the beautiful was not so aesthetically appreciated by the players, however.  The field which had been in excellent condition became slimy with a coating of wet snow.  The players who wore tennis shoes through the game could get no foothold whatever. After a few minutes these were discarded, given a healthy fling in some direction or other ,and for the rest of the game the strenuous and elusive pigskin was chased in stocking feet.  Even cleats did not hold any too well and a flying tackle which had any steam at all behind it was likely to come to a halt some twenty feet from where the players hit the dumps.  The intervening space resembled the initial attempt of a fifty cent fountain pen on a sheet of white paper.  Veritable drifts collected on the heads and shoulders of the players who could not run fast enough to get from under.  Eyes and ears were filled with miniature drifts and at least one fumble was caused by the coating of ice with which the ball was richly garnished.

As to the game itself, without any kidding, it was worth the money, especially to the liberal smattering of deadheads commonly known as chair weights.  It was worth while if for no other reason in the world than to get a few points on how the game is played.  When the two teams lined up there w as little doubt but what they were in for a hard and grueling match.  It took but twenty seconds of play to see on which side of the fence the fowl of victory would descend.  Massillon kicked off like a whirlwind, and not only downed the bewildered runner on his own twenty yard line, but held the ball there on downs. Alliance punted and Massillon carried the ball back to within striking distance of the goal.  The first two touchdowns were made in the first minute of play.  From this time on Massillon’s relentless scoring machine walked up the field and over the line at will.

Only once was Alliance within any danger of making a point.  This was one of the numerous kickoffs, when the ball, after bounding on the right side of the field was secured by Alliance, on Massillon’s twenty-five yard line.  In a moment of weakness the Alliance full back pierced Massillon’s right side for five yards.  Hope sprang sky high beneath the red and white jerseys, but each presumption was immediately sat upon.  The next play was dumped behind the line, and Massillon secured the ball on the next.  Throughout the game Alliance became more and more dumpy, and held less and less as the game progressed.  The full back and right end, however, played good games and stuck to the firing line until the last dog was hung.

Massillon’s playing was aggressive to the degree of monotony.  Every play was tried and almost every member on the team was indulgently awarded the honor of making a touchdown.  Alliance could not see through the playing for smoke,.  Bang! Bang! Bang! Massillon would hit the line with glee.  Bang!  The whole Alliance team would pile desperately under the play; but no, somehow or other, someone or other had surreptitiously sneaked around the back way, and was beating it down the field for anywhere from ten yards to half the length of the field.  In the second half Captain Hammersmith left the game with a new Charley horse, this time in his right leg. Reese went in at right end.  Blackburn, whose trusty boot turned the trick in the Canton game, was in hard luck Saturday.  A yellow streak in his right toe prevented several spectacular goals.

The teams lined up as follows:

Alliance     Pos.        Massillon
Jones             le              Kelly
Godddard       lt                 Erb
Kallenbaugh   lg          Heyman
Tanner            c              Davis
Iden              rg       Blackburn
Sorn               rt               Clay
Mummert      re   Wells, Reese
Davis            qb          Atwater
Iger                lh  Hammersmith and Wells
Aloot             rh           Snavely
Newshutz      fb      Sonnhalter

Time of halves:  20 minutes.

Touchdowns:
Massillon – Sonnhalter 4; Hammersmith 3; Wells  2;  Clay 1; Erb 1; Snavely  1.

Goals from touchdown:
Massillon – Blackburn  1; Heyman  3.

Referee – Merwin,
Linesman – Bloomberg.
Timekeepers – Hall and Coleman.

History

1908: Massillon 12 Canton Central 6

MASSILLON HIGH
WON THE DAY
A Tigerish Game Was
Won in Whirlwind Fashion.
SCORE:  MASSILLON  12,  CANTON   6

The Black and Gold Trimmed a Tough Proposition in the Last Five Minutes of Play

The Enthusiasm was Unbounded

In the hardest and fastest gridiron battle ever waged in the history of the local school, Massillon high for the first time in twelve years sent its old time rival, Canton high, down to defeat Saturday afternoon by the score of 12 to 6.  After thirty-eight minutes of play in wihich the two teams, fighting like tigers, see-sawed back and forth across the field, both teams broke loose in a fit of desperation and three touchdowns were raced over the line in whirlwind fashion.  With but eight minutes left to play, L. Wise secured the ball on what appeared to be a fumble and chased behind the two posts for Canton’s first and only touchdown.  In the last five minutes of play Massillon came to its own.  After a fumble by Canton the ball, chased by half a dozen players of both sides, bounded behind the goal posts where Davis, of Massillon, fell on it.

It was Massillon’s turn now and the enthusiasm was unbounded.  Blackburn kicked a faultless goal but the game was not yet won.  A few minutes later another of Heyman’s long spiral punts was fumbled on the ten yard line.  Blackburn secured the ball and trotted over for the second and decisive touchdown.  If enthusiasm was wild before it was frantic now.  Massillon’s small but loyal bunch of rooters jumped and fell and rolled from the grandstand onto the field in an ecstasy of joy.  Every voice was shouted hoarse.  The players embraced one another and wept upon Blackburn’s neck.  A perfect goal gave a new lease of life to the unquenchable outburst.

There was yet one minute and thirteen seconds to play and the desperate wearers of the black and red determined to make this count for at least a tie.  But it could not be.  Massillon considered the game over and won, and by frantic efforts Canton carried the ball on crashing line bucks to within twenty-three inches of Massillon’s goal.

Here Massillon held like a stone wall and on the third down and goal to gain, with five more seconds to play, Canton took time out to regain its wind. Behind the goal posts was a howling mob; Massillon rooters yelling like mad to hold, hold, hold and Canton supporters crying frantically for a touchdown.  Things happened fast in the next few seconds.  The ball was put into play, and the giant McGregor, wheeling into action, bore down upon Massillon’s left side.  The compact was crushing, but Erb and Heyman held.  The next moment Massillon’s backfield crashed into the breach, and as the whistle blew for time the pigskin settled back two feet from Massillon’s inviolate goal.  The trick was turned and Massillon had come to her own.

Canton lays its defeat to a weakened line-up, but although Massillon was strengthened by the addition of Sonnhalter and Heyman, recently of the second team, they were weakened as much or more than Canton by the lack of a left end.  Kelly, who was relied upon, had his toe injured in practice, and Richards failed to show up at the last minute.  Moody held the position down well, considering the fact that he had been playing guard all season.  The real cause, however, lies deeper. Both teams played hard, both desperately at times, but in Massillon’s defensive playing was a Carlysle daring recklessness which knew no fear and nailed the man at any cost.  On offensive was displayed careful plugging tactics, and a readiness to profit by the least incident which was Johnny on the spot from start to finish. It was this which gave Massillon the ball on the fumbles and which put over the touchdowns before any one could impede.  Behind it all lay Heyman’s great punting.  Fifty yards was often covered through his great booting, and the speed of Massillon’s line in getting down the field and nailing the man held the ball most of the time in Canton’s territory.  More than this a difficult spiral curve made it almost impossible to catch one of the punts. Invariable fumbling on the part of Canton’s backfield gave Massillon its two decisive touchdowns.

Every one of Massillon’s players covered himself with glory.  There was not a waver, not a moment of indecision.  There could not have been, and still have allowed the score to remain as it did.  Every player was in the game heart and soul, to do or die, from start to finish.  Both guards, Heyman and Blackburn, played their positions well, but eclipsed their record here by their perfect kicking and other exploits.  Davis, at center, held his man, beside making one of the two touchdowns.  Clay and Erb, the two massive tackles, were towers of strength on each wing and allowed no gain except such as could be shoved over their prostrate bodies.  Atwater, at quarter, not only ran the team to victory, but defended the goal perfectly and ran back punts in first class shape.  Hammersmith and Snavely played their usual hard and fast game at the halves, blocking the line and nailing end runs.  Sonnhalter, at full, was the backbone of the team not only gaining often on offensive, but blocking a thousand holes in the line through which the ball might otherwise have been shoved for decided gains.  Coach Hall was jubilant over the result of the game and feels that Massillon’s real form has at last arrived.

The teams lined up as follows:

Canton – 6                      Pos.               Massillon – 12.
Blythe                               le                              Moody
Gauchat, L. Wise               lt                                    Erb
Blanchard                          lg                            Heyman
Wise, Lash                        c                                 Davis
Carper                              rg                         Blackburn
Lothamer                           rt                                  Clay
Zeiter                                re                                Wells
Kahler                              qb                            Atwater
Steiner, Smalley                 lh                    Hammersmith
Harris                               rh                             Snavely
McGregor                         fb                         Sonnhalter

Score end of first half:
Canton – 0
Massillon – 0.

Touchdowns:
Canton – L. Wise.
Massillon – Davis; Blackburn.

Goals from touchdowns:
Canton – Blythe  1.
Massillon – Blackburn  2.

Failed goal from field:
Canton – McGregor  2; Blythe.

Referee and Umpire – Hazlett of Canton.

History

1908: Massillon 0 Canton Central 17

MASSILLON HIGH DIED GAME
Put Up a First Class Contest Against Canton
CANTON,  17;       MASSILLON, 0.

McGregor, Disabled,
Went Into the Game and Turned the Tide of Battle
Massillon Carried the Ball to Canton’s Ten-Yard Line
but Couldn’t Put it Over.

Although defeated in the end by the score of 17 to 0, the Massillon high school football team managed to give Canton’s aggregation the worst scare it has received in many a long day when the two teams met for the first time this season on the high school grounds, Saturday afternoon.  Expecting a one-sided score which could be reckoned by tens, it ran into a snag in the very first scrimmage, which promised to be its undoing.  The day was only saved by rushing the disabled McGregor, Canton’s massive and invincible fullback, into a suit, and trotting him out to hunt for the weak spots in Massillon’s stone wall defense.  With few exceptions he was the only man who could make a dent in Massillon’s light but scrappy line.  When he did not carry the ball he made the hole for the other fellow.  The advent of the heavy full back was not noticed at once but in the long run he proved the deciding weight in the scales of victory.

Massillon was more than an even match for the original team with which Canton started the game.  Receiving on the first kickoff it made its yards repeatedly against the dazed Canton team, which had not anticipated such things.  Massillon’s greatest playing was done in the first ten minutes of the second half.  The same can be said of Canton, for in this time the two teams held against each other like two walls of adamant, the ball changing hands several times without moving more than a yard or two either way.  Massillon received the ball on the kickoff in the second half and carried it without losing it, to Canton’s ten yard line.  One touchdown and a goal meant victory for Massillon.  With victory ten short yards off, Massillon played like a demon, but Canton, goaded by fear of defeat, held in desperation.  Every hole in the red and black line was plugged by Canton backs.  Massillon’s every trick was tried but Canton’s ends were wise and refused to be drawn in.  Erb dropped back for a try at goal but the kick was blocked.  Massillon recovered the ball and the battle royal began again.  Twice the ball was lost and gained by Massillon on fumbles, but with twelve downs in succession the ball was not advanced an inch.  Twice Massillon had but one man between the runner and the goal, but twice this man nailed the play.  Atwater and Snavely carried the ball in these cases and carried it back for thirty yards, being downed by the last man between himself and the goal.

Canton soon came to its own.  Receiving the ball on a punt it took a mighty brace and bore slowly through Massillon’s line, carrying the ball down the field on plunging line bucks.  After losing the ball several times it at last forced it over for the second touchdown.  The third touchdown was secured by the same tactics, although Massillon’s line never said die, and fought for all that was in it until the whistle blew.  In the latter part of the second half Massillon punted every time it received the ball.  It had not given up the hope of scoring but considered this the only manner in which it could again get within striking distance of the goal.  Massillon’s good work in downing the runner where the ball dropped made this possible.

Massillon’s playing exceeded the hopes of the most sanguine.  The line played low, the backs ran low, and the tackling was not only low but hard.  There was no dragging.  When a man was hit he knew it, and he faded without delay.  Behind the playing on both sides was a Carlisle desperation, which brooked no trifling.  Canton had thought Massillon would be easy and was desperate with the fear of defeat.  Massillon knew that if ever under the sun, now was a chance to defeat Canton, and it was determined to do it.  Every player was in the game to do or to die.  Canton turned the trick, and Massillon died game.  The score may after all be a fair estimate of the strength of the two teams for Canton easily outweighed Massillon ten or fifteen pounds to the man.  This counted for little until the final test in the second half, when it won the game.  A practical demonstration of Massillon’s ginger was Dave Reese, its 120 pound center who played the game against three different opponents of massive proportions and who stuck them all out.

An unprecedented crowd of over a thousand people boxed the field on all sides, and with the exception of a few Canton adherents, gave Massillon its undivided loyalty.  If anything under the sun aided Massillon in the accomplishment of such great things it was the heroic loyalty of two hundred high school students, principally girls who took their stand at the north side of the field and yelled and shouted and sang themselves hoarse for the yellow and black in defeat and victory.

Following is the line-up:
Canton – 17                    Pos.                  Massillon – 0
Blythe (c)                          le                            Richards
L. Wise                             lt                                    Erb
Howells                             lg                                  Carr
C. Wise                             c                                Reese
Karper                              rg                         Blackburn
Lathamer                           rt                                  Clay
Cover                               re                                Wells
Brooks                             qb                            Atwater
Harris                               rh                             Snavely
Steiner                              lh               Hammersmith (c)
Lawson, McGregor           fb                                Davis

Time of halves:  20 minutes.

Touchdowns:  Canton – McGregor  2; Blythe.

Goals from touchdown:  Canton – Brooks  2.

Referee – Bast.
Timekeeper – Hall.
Linesman – Bloomberg.

History

1908: Massillon 0 Dover 26

DOVER WHITEWASHED THE HIGH SCHOOL
DOVER  26                 MASSILLON   0

Nothing was added to the percentage of the Massillon High School football team nor to its unenviable reputation on the gridiron by the game played at Canal Dover, Saturday.  Massillon was defeated by a team weighing much less, and showing much less practice in the playing of the game; and not only this, but by a score much higher than it had any cause whatever to be.  The score was 26 to 0.  The Massillon team was confident perhaps over confident, as to the outcome of the game, but it had reason to be.  Massillon was equal to the task of beating Dover but when weighed in the balance something was lacking.  The local team did not play so badly as it did listlessly and therein lies the cause of defeat.

Massillon weight helped some, and there was some individual playing but not enough.  The snap and vim with which Dover played was almost wholly lacking in the other team.  Dover’s readiness to take advantage of Massillon’s drowsiness and failure to see through trick plays was the most important factor in Massillon’s defeat.  Massillon did not seem to ginger into the game until the second half when its real form was shown to excellent advantage but it was then too late.

Dover made five touchdowns, three in the first and two in the second half.  A little trick which started Massillon up in the air was a short side kick on the kick-off which was recovered by a Dover man.  The first touchdown was made after, twelve minutes of play.  Not more than two of Dover’s touchdowns were forced over on straight football.  Most of the gains were made by tricks and running in the open field, all of which should have been stopped by Massillon players.  At the most a half-hearted attempt was made when a little extra effort would have stopped the play.  Massillon tacklers were staved off with the greatest ease.

In the second half after being stepped on to pretty good advantage, the Massillon players began to get hot under the collar.  In certain spots during this part of the game they showed form which should have won the game for them had it been apparent during the entire game.  At times the ball was carried along for substantial gains, but Dover’s nervy playing usually took the starch out of any attempts at a touchdown.  Once, however, the ball was run straight up the field to within one yard of the goal.  Erb was called back from his tackle to put the ball over the line which he would have done with the greatest case had not Bowers, who was playing quarter, fumbled.  Dover secured the ball and punted out.  The Massillon team lost its last chance to save itself for a whitewash.

History

1908: Massillon 0 Akron 40

AKRON HIGH TOO
MUCH FOR THEM
Massillon Stacks Up Against
a Snag and Loses Out.

SCORE – AKRON  40    MASSILLON   0
The Akron Team Took Twenty-nine Points in the First Half,
but Massillon Tightened Up and Held it to Eleven in the Second.

Akron high’s beef, speed and superior team work was too much for the Massillon high school eleven, which met the Akron school at Akron Saturday.  After forty-five minutes of play Massillon retired from the contest forty-four points in the hole and without a score to its credit.  Unlike the score, however, the playing was not all one sided.  Massillon played in general a hard game but it could not prevail against hits heavier opponents.  There was some good individual playing on the part of the Massillon players, but the general team work was loose and afforded Akron, which played well together, a chance to open up the weak spots.  A good sized score was piled up by Akron in spite of the fact that most of the penalties of the game were called against its players.  Off side playing was the offense losing most of the ground.

The only play which Akron was unable to play was its forward pass.  The play called a man far too one side who was to receive the ball and throw it over the line.  Massillon, however, guarded the man well and the ball was never thrown.  Instead the player cut into the line and was downed without gain.  Other forward passes were broken up by Massillon, causing Akron to lose much on penalties.  Akron’s largest gains were made by straight line bucking.  Weak spots were found all along.  Holes were opened and the runner trotted through, for substantial gains each time.  A triple pass from a tandem on tackle also worked well for Akron.

Massillon was usually held for downs and forced to punt.  Snavely did the kicking.  Massillon’s line did not hold well and consequently the backfield was unable to form proper interference.  Considering the odds Massillon put up a tolerable game.  Akron averaged over 150 pounds while Massillon averages nearer 135.  Akron was also much faster and showed excellent team work.  The first touchdown was made on a fumble sidewise pass, but all the rest were put over the line on straight football.  Only one goal was kicked.  A goal from field counted Akron 4.  Massillon did not take an official along but received an eminently square deal in all parts of the game.

Following is the line-up:

Akron        Pos.        Massillon
Hollinger        le          Atwater, Richards
Zimmerman     lt                 Erb
Scheck, Boath                      lg       Blackburn
Franks            c             Reese
Anderson      rg         Burkhart, Leahy and Moody
Criss              rt               Clay
Williams, Ault re              Wells
Quinn           qb          Bowers, Atwater
Baer, Smith, Sigel              lh  Hammersmith
Jackson         rh           Snavely
Zook, Smith  fb              Davis

Time of halves – 20 and 25 minutes.

Touchdowns:
Akron – Jackson  3; Zook; Zimmerman  2; Hollinger.

Place kick:
Akron – Jackson.

Referee – Cally.
Umpire – Stevens.
Time Keeper – Hall and Moore.
Linesmen – Cass, Blackwood and Leahy.

History

1908: Massillon 0 Salem 37

HIGH SCHOOL AT SALEM
Massillon – 0        Salem – 37

In a sea of mud and in a downpour of rain, Massillon’s high school football team went down to defeat Saturday at Salem by the score of 37 to 0.  The condition of the field was such that little or nothing of the open and spectacular game could be attempted.  Heavy and plodding playing was the only kind which could make the ground and in this particular the Salem eleven excelled.  The forward pass could not be worked to any advantage at all.  Massillon lost the ball several times on this.  In summing up the game, however, it may be said that it was won by team work.  Salem in general playing together, especially in running interference.  Massillon played hard but could avail little.

Some good playing, however, was done by Massillon.  Almost every tackle made by Massillon was a good one and few which were not so low as possible were as effective.  After the first touchdown in the first half the general trend of the game was seen and Hammersmith went in to stop up the breach.  He played a hard and fast game, making most of Massillon’s few gains.  The only play by which Massillon was able to make substantial gains was a fake end run on a trick tackle play.  This worked several times for good distances.  Snavely and Hammersmith carried the ball on these.  Salem’s line of baby elephants held too hard for gains in this direction.  Dave Reese, Massillon’s 120 pound center, played to good advantage against his 190 pound opponent.  Salem’s biggest Shelton, a 210 pound guard.  These played no defensive game but blocked the holes effectively.

Massillon’s one objection was to the refereeing of Salem’s official, who in certain cases seemed to have it in for Massillon.  In one case the ball was carried back on an unsuccessful forward pass and put into play at the place from which the scrimmage started instead of being carried back fifteen yards.  Other cases were patent.  This would not of course have won the game but it may have changed the score considerably.  Objection was futile as Massillon had no official on the field.  In other ways Massillon was fairly well treated but the players accepted the situation with good grace and have no kick to register.

Following is the way the teams lined up:

Salem        Pos.        Massillon
Hise              re          Atwater
Grice              rt               Clay
Shelton          rg       Blackburn
Tolerton          c             Leahy
Lynn              lg               Carr
McConnor      lt                 Erb
Rogers           le Richards, Wells
Muff             qb           Bowers
Willaman       rh           Snavely
Cray              lh              Wells, Hammersmith
Theiff             fb              Davis

History

1908: Massillon 12 Alliance 23

HIGH SCHOOL
vs.
ALLIANCE
Massillon – 12      Alliance – 23

It was Massillon’s more or less listless playing in the first half of the game which allowed the Alliance high school team to run up 17 decisive points on the local school at Mt. Union Saturday and thereby win the game.  In the second half Massillon was desperate and determined to win.  Two touchdowns and two goals were made and Massillon seemed on the high road to victory when time was called.  Too much dependence was put into the shortest half.  The final score was 23 to 12.

In the first half before Massillon had properly gingered into the game, Alliance had its own way.  Massillon held stubbornly, but loosely and without vim.  Alliance could usually make its yards, but seldom more.  Only once in the first half did it look as if the tide of battle would turn decisively Massillon found Alliance’s weak spot, and hammered it unmercifully for more than half the length of the field.  Davis gained continually through Alliances right guard, Blackburn opening the hole.  Cross bucks also were good gainers.  But the ball was lost on downs on Alliance’s five yard line, and Massillon was again carried back.

In the second half the worm did turn, and Massillon showed what she really was worth.  Two touchdowns were force over, one on straight football by Snavely, and the other secured by Richards on a fumble.  Both goals were kicked faultlessly by Blackburn.  The Massillon team gingered up with vim, and held Alliance for downs.

Alliance’s plunging full back was its greatest gainer, and all round player.  He was the heaviest man on the team and made practically all of Alliance’s gains.  Massillon’s line was strong but it did not show until the second half.  Blqackburn and Erb opened up the big hole through which Massillon gained the most.  Clay on the other side of the line played the big defensive game.  If anyone lay down in front of him he walked right over him, and if anyone stood in front of him he walked anyway.  More than once he downed the runner behind the line, and was down the field on the kick-off with the best of them.  Snavely and Davis made Massillon’s big gains.  Massillon used the forward pass successfully several times, Snavely receiving the ball.  Alliance however, could not make it work to very good advantage.  Alliance skirted the ends for substantial gains twice on the fake punt, Massillon’s ends being drawn in.

Alliance – 23                   Pos. Massillon – 12
Mummert       le           Moody
Shern              lt             Leahy
Iden               lg               Clay
Tanner            c         Burkhart
Kallenbaugh   lg       Blackburn
Goddard         lt                 Erb
Jones             le         Richards
Davis            qb           Bowers
Wingert         rh              Wells
Alloot            lh           Snavely
Newshutz (c) fb              Davis

Time – 25 and 20 minute halves

Touchdowns:
Massillon – Snavely; Richards.
Alliance – Newshutz, 2; Wingert; Mummert.

Goal from touchdown:
Massillon – Blackburn.

Referee – Jones.
Timekeeper – Hall.
Linesman – Hammersmith.

History

1908: Massillon 0 Massillon Actual Business College 11

BEEF TRUST
TOO MUCH FOR THEM.
High School Succumbs to the Business College.
MASSILLON  — 0      BUSINESS COLLEGE – 11
STUDENTS DIE IN THE LAST DITCH

The Hard but Rather Loose Game
Resulted in the Score of 11 to 0 in Favor of M.A.B.C.
A Massive Line Buck by the College Made the Yards.

It was Yocum’s Consolidated Beef Trust that sat down on the high school football team Wednesday afternoon on the high school grounds and tried to smother the life out of it to the tune of 11 to 0.  But the high school refused to smother.  In spite of the flying wedges, and through guard bucks of the business college, the smaller high school players stuck to their posts through it all and were holding the line plunges better in the last five minutes of play than at any time before.  The business college could usually make its yards through the line, and usually did it, but the high school players were undismayed at any stage of the game.  Time and again they threw themselves into the breaches in the line and checked progress by the dead weight of their bodies.  A few times the plucky playing held the college for downs.

In the open playing where speed and skill is necessary, the high school easily excelled.  At one time near the end of the first half the high school gaining continually on end runs and threatened to put the ball over the line.  In running back punts the high school was more accurate, the business college fumbling often and losing rather than gaining.  In the first half the ball was fumbled and driven back of the line by the player who should have received it.  He was tackled behind the line.  It was called a touch back, but no appeal was made from the decision.  Shoemaker and Mouse, the two massive guards for the business college, were the ones who tore the holes in the high school’s line.  Ellis at right end, played a fast game, and did some good work in carrying the ball.  The biggest gainer for the college was a play in which one of the big guards was called back and sent through the line in a mass tandem on tackle.  The college’s three backs played hard and fast game.

Most of the high school’s playing was defensive.  The team played hard and blocked the holes to the best of its ability.  Only once in a while did the college make anything around end, but when she once broke away it was for a substantial gain.  On offensive the high school made her best gains on a line shift end run, Snavely carrying the ball.  The business college bucked the ball over the line on straight football, once in the first and once in the second half.  Goal was kicked the first time by Bury.

The line up follows:

M.H.S. – 0                 Pos. Bus. College – 11
Richards        le          Allander
Erb                 lt              Stark
Black             lg            Mouse
Burkhart         c            Young
Shoemaker    rg               Carr
Burry             rt             Leahy
Ellis               re           Moody
Bowers        qb    F. Swanson
C. Swanson   lh              Wells
Downy          rh           Snavely
Schnierle       fb              Davis

Time:  15 minutes halves

Referee – Miller.
Umpire – Bloomberg.
Timekeeper – Hall.

History

1908: Massillon 7 Dover 5

CHARLEY-HORSE
DIDN’T STOP HIM.
Hammersmith Participated in Defeat of Dover.

MADE SAFETY AND TOUCHDOWN.
MASSILLON  7        DOVER   5

Massillon Outweighed Visitors Ten Pounds to the Man
and Had Greater Endurance
Local Eleven Exhibited Ginger and Strength but Little Science.

It was Johnnie Hammersmith, Massillon’s thunder and lightning halfback who played the winning game Saturday against Dover high school football team, on the high school grounds.  Hammer was in the game from start to finish and played the whole second half with a cramp known as a Charley Horse among the initiated, in his left leg.  The injury was not received in the game but was due to overexertion of single muscles in practice.  In the first half Hammer was first down the field on the second kick off and downed the Dover man behind the line, scoring Massillon’s first two points on a safety.  In the second half it was Hammer who carried the ball over the line on an end run from the ten yard line, scoring five more points and winning the game.  After fifteen minutes of play in the first half Dover made its only five points.  After netting thirty-five yards on a forward pass and bucking the line for five yards, Klar carried the ball over for Dover in a mass play on left tackle.

In general the two teams were evenly matched.  Massillon outweighed Dover perhaps ten pounds to the man, but Dover has been practicing for a month to Massillon’s week and a half and it showed it.  In the matter of endurance Massillon again had the advantage.  Dover started off like a whirlwind but before the end of the first half Massillon had it so completely fogged that time was taken out four times by the Dover team, which was penalized two yards for the last time, each team being allowed to call time out but three times in a half.  The deciding factor in the game, however, was Massillon’s invincible determination to win the first game.  Much depended upon the outcome.  There is a project on foot among the citizens of Massillon to back the team financially and to purchase a complete outfit for the team in place it makes good.  Between the halves Superintendent Cronebaugh told the team there was $200 in sight if it won the game.  Coach Hall exhorted each player to his mightiest deeds and Massillon went out and won.  It was do or die, and they did.

Considering the recent organization of the Massillon team and the number of new men in the lineup, their playing was excellent.  But five, Erb, Carr, Hammersmith, Snavely and Wells, are veterans.  The remainder are this year’s recruits.  Bowers as quarter, generaled the team like a veteran.  The right play was forth coming at the right time and the weak spots were “Hammered” unmercifully.  Burkhart at center, Leahy at tackle, and Richards t end, buckled into the opposing line like old timers.  The game brought out many weak points, however, which will be remedied as soon as possible.  Klar and Benson played the game for Dover.
THE GAME
Snavely kicked off to Benson, who advanced fifteen yards.  Casbeer was thrown for a loss, Benson failed to gain around left end, Klar punted to Hammersmith.  Hammersmith made six yards around right end.  Snavely was thrown without gain.  Dover caught on side kick.  Benson made six yards through right guard.  Dover penalized five yards for holding.  Benson failed to gain. Klar punted to Hammersmith, Snavely failed to gain.  Kickout failed.  Score, Dover 5; Massillon 0.

Snavely kicked off to Peters who fumbled ball and was down by Hammersmith across the line.  Massillon awared a safety.  Score, Dover 5; Massillon 2.

Dover kicked out from twenty-five yard line.  Massillon’s ball.  Hammersmith failed to gain, Snavely fumbled, Hammersmith recovering ball, Snavely punted to Klar who returned fifteen yards, Benson made two yards around left end.  A forward pass failed.  Time called.  Score Dover 5; Massillon 2.
SECOND HALF
Klar kicked to Hammersmith who returned fifteen yards.  Hammersmith failed to gain, Snavely failed to gain, Casbeer blocked Snavely’s punt, Hammersmith recovering ball, Snavely failed to gain through guard, Hammersmith made seven yards around right end, Hammersmith punted to Klar who returned twenty yards; downed by Carr.  Benson fumbled, Richards recovering the ball, Hammersmith failed to gain.  A forward pass netted twenty yards, Snavely gained three yards through left guard.  Dover was penalized five yards for holding.  Hammersmith gained two yards.  Dover penalized two-yards for holding.  Davis failed to gain around right end.  Hammersmith made a touchdown on right end run for ten yards.  The kickout failed.  Score, Massillon 7; Dover 5.

Snavely kicked off to Benson who returned fifteen yards.  Klar fumbled, giving Massillon the ball.  Davis made three yards through tackle.  Hammersmith failed to gain, on-side kick and failed.  Dover’s ball.  Klar fumbled.  Hammersmith falling on ball.  Davis made two yards, Hammersmith fumbled.  Dover’s ball.  A forward pass netted fifteen yards, Klar made five yards through tackle, Benson made three yards, Casbeer made two yards, Casbeer made seven yards around end, Peters made three yards through left tackle, Klar made three yards through right guard, Casbeer made five yards, Casbeer made three yards, Klar failed to gain, forward pass failed.  Richards falling on ball, Hammersmith punted to Klar who was downed by Richards.  Time up.  Score,

Klar made five yards through right guard, Benson failed to make gain.  Massillon’s ball.  Hammersmith made ten yards around right end.  Davis made two yards around left end, Snavely failed to gain, Hammersmith punted to Klar, thrown by Snavely, Benson thrown for a loss.  A forward pass netted thirty-five yards.  Benson made five yards through right tackle, Klar carried the ball over the line.  Score:  Massillon  7;  Dover 5.

The line-up:

Massillon – 7                 Pos.       Dover – 5
Richards        le            Brister
Erb                 lt             Athey
Moody          lg     A. Godfrey
Burkhart         c              Davis
Carr              rg        Wendling
Leahy             rt             Peters
Wells             re      J. Godfrey
Bowers        qb         Radswell
Hammersmith lh          Casbeer
Davis             rh           Benson
Snavely         fb                Klar

Summary:
Halves:  20 and 15 minutes.

Umpire – Merwin.
Referee – Dow.
Time keeper – Hall.
Head Linesman – Bloomberg