| 52 | 1937-42 | Paul Brown, Bud Houghton, Elwood Kammer | Canton McKinley | Wins / Ties |
| 38 | 1937-41 | Paul Brown, Bud Houghton | Mansfield (tie) | Wins |
| 32 | 1963-66 | Leo Strang, Earl Bruce, Bob Seaman | Niles McKinley | Wins / Ties |
| 31 | 1977-80 | Mike Currence | Canton McKinley | Wins / Ties / Reg. Season |
| 30 | 1963-66 | Leo Strang, Earl Bruce, Bob Seaman | Mansfield (tie) | Wins |
| 26 | 1935-37 | Paul Brown | New Castle, PA | Wins / Ties |
| 25 | 1951-54 | Chuck Mather, Tom Harp | Alliance | Wins |
| 22 | 1977-79 | Mike Currence | Parma Padua | Wins / Ties |
| 21 | 1935-37 | Paul Brown | Mansfield (tie) | Wins |
| 21 | 1971-73 | Bob Commings | Canton McKinley | Wins / Ties / Reg. Season |
| 20 | 1949-51 | Chuck Mather | Warren Harding | Wins |
| 20 | 1958-60 | Leo Strang | Warren Harding | Wins |
| 16 | 1954-55 | Tom Harp | Canton McKinley | Wins / Ties |
| 16 | 1971-73 | Bob Commings | Clev. Benedictine | Wins / Reg. Season |
| 15 | 1999-00 | Rick Shepas | Clev. St. Ignatius | Wins / Reg. Season |
| 14 | 1960-61 | Leo Strang | Fremont Ross | Wins |
| 14 | 2012-13 | Jason Hall | Austintown Fitch | Wins / Reg. Season |
| 14 | 2018 | Nate Moore | Akron Hoban | Wins |
| 13 | 1921-23 | Dave Stewart | Harrisburg Tech, PA | Wins |
| 13 | 1970-71 | Bob Commings | Niles McKinley | Wins |
| 12 | 1908-10 | Hap Fugate | East Clev. Shaw | Wins / Ties |
| 12 | 1954-55 | Tom Harp | Mansfield (tie) | Wins |
| 12 | 1978-79 | Mike Currence | Parma Padua | Wins |
| 12 | 1982 | Mike Currence | Cincinnati Moeller | Wins |
| 11 | 1916-17 | John Snavely | New Philadelphia | Wins |
| 11 | 1943-44 | Elwood Kammer | Clev. Cathedral Latin | Wins |
| 11 | 1982-83 | Mike Currence | Akron Garfield | Wins / Reg. Season |
| 10 | 1945 | Augie Morningstar | Clev. Cathedral Latin | Wins / Ties |
| 10 | 1948-49 | Chuck Mather | Mansfield | Wins |
| 10 | 1957-58 | Lee Tressel, Leo Strang | Warren Harding | Wins / Ties |
| 10 | 1994-95 | Jack Rose | Mansfield | Wins / Reg. Season |
| 10 | 1999 | Rick Shepas | Massillon Perry | Wins |
| 10 | 2012 | Jason Hall | Toledo Whitmer | Wins |
