| RANK | PLAYER | RECORD | OPPONENT | YEAR | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RANK | PLAYER | POINTS | OPPONENT | YEAR | |
| POINTS | 1 | Edwin Hill | 48 | Akron North | 1922 |
| POINTS | 2 | Heine Krier | 45 | Youngstown South | 1934 |
| POINTS | 3t | D.C. McCants | 36 | Columbus Aquinas | 1933 |
| POINTS | 3t | Wendell Lohr | 36 | Barberton | 1934 |
| POINTS | 3t | John Francisco | 36 | Akron South | 1951 |
| POINTS | 6 | Jimmy Price | 34 | Akron Central | 1923 |
| POINTS | 7 | Bob Glass | 32 | Franklin, Cedar Rapids, IA | 1937 |
| POINTS | 8t | Jamir Thomas | 30 | Canisius, NY | 2017 |
| POINTS | 8t | Edwin Hill | 30 | Cambridge | 1922 |
| POINTS | 8t | Travis McGuire | 30 | Canton McKinley | 1991 |
| POINTS | 8t | Terrance Keyes, Jr. | 30 | Barberton | 2019 |
| RANK | PLAYER | TOUCHDOWNS | OPPONENT | YEAR | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 1 | Edwin Hill | 8 | Akron North | 1922 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 2 | Heine Krier | 7 | Youngstown South | 1934 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 3t | D.C. McCants | 6 | Columbus Aquinas | 1933 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 3t | Wendell Lohr | 6 | Barberton | 1934 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 3t | John Francisco | 6 | Akron South | 1951 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Edwin Hill | 5 | Cambridge | 1922 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Jimmy Price | 5 | Akron Central | 1923 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Bob Glass | 5 | Franklin, Cedar Rapids, IA | 1937 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Falando Ashcraft | 5 | Youngstown East | 1991 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Travis McGuire | 5 | Canton McKinley | 1991 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Jamir Thomas | 5 | Canisius, NY | 2017 |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | Terrance Keyes, Jr. | 5 | Barberton | 2019 |