| RANK | PLAYER | PAT KICKS MADE | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 1 | Alex Bauer | 14 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 2 | Steve Schott | 10 | Friendship Edison, DC | 2004 |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 3t | Jerry Krisher | 9 | Steubenville | 1949 |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 3t | Jason Brown | 9 | Youngstown East | 1991 |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 3t | Nate Gregg | 9 | Toledo Bowsher | 2016 |
| PAT KICKS MADE | 6t | (several) | 8 | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 1 | Alex Bauer | 14 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 2 | Nate Gregg | 11 | Toledo Bowsher | 2016 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 3t | Jason Brown | 10 | Youngstown East | 1991 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 3t | Max Shafer | 10 | Fremont Ross | 2002 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 3t | Steve Schott | 10 | Friendship Edison, DC | 2004 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 6 | Jerry Krisher | 9 | Steubenville | 1949 |
| PAT KICKS ATTEMPTED | 7t | (several) | 8 | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | FIELD GOALS MADE | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 1 | David Abdul | 4 | Lima Senior | 2000 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | David Abdul | 3 | Akron Garfield | 2000 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | Max Shafer | 3 | Mansfield | 2003 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | Steve Schott | 3 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2006 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | Jeremy Geier | 3 | Akron Garfield | 2009 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | Andrew David | 3 | Canton McKinley | 2012 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 2t | Alex Bauer | 3 | Lakewood St. Edward | 2020 |
| FIELD GOALS MADE | 8t | (several) | 2 | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 1 | David Abdul | 5 | Lima Senior | 2000 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 2t | Mike Norris | 4 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 1985 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 2t | David Abdul | 4 | Austintown Fitch | 2001 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 2t | Andrew David | 4 | Canton GlenOak | 2013 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 2t | Steve Schott | 4 | Warren Harding | 2004 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 2t | Steve Schott | 4 | Dover | 2005 |
| FIELD GOALS ATTEMPTED | 7t | (several) | 3 | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | LONGEST FIELD GOAL | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 1 | Andrew David | 58 | St. John's Collegiate, ON | 2014 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 2 | David Abdul | 56 | Akron Garfield | 2000 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 3 | David Abdul | 54 | Mansfield | 2001 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 4 | David Abdul | 53 | Austintown Fitch | 2001 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 5 | David Abdul | 52 | Lakewood St. Edward | 2000 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 6t | David Abdul | 51 | Mt. Lebanon, PA | 2001 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 6t | David Abdul | 51 | Westerville South | 2001 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 6t | Andrew David | 51 | Akron Garfield | 2014 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 9t | David Abdul | 50 | Akron Buchtel | 2000 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 9t | David Abdul | 50 | Marion Harding | 2000 |
| LONGEST FIELD GOAL | 9t | Andrew David | 50 | Canton GlenOak | 2014 |
| | | | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | POINTS KICKING | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| POINTS KICKING | 1 | Alex Bauer | 17 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 |
| POINTS KICKING | 2 | Jeremy Geier | 14 | Akron Garfield | 2009 |
| POINTS KICKING | 3t | Andrew David | 13 | Canton McKinley | 2012 |
| POINTS KICKING | 3t | Andrew David | 13 | St. John's Collegiate, ON | 2014 |
| POINTS KICKING | 3t | Steve Schott | 13 | Mansfield | 2005 |
| POINTS KICKING | 6t | Steve Schott | 12 | Akron Buchtel | 2007 |
| POINTS KICKING | 6t | Alex Bauer | 12 | Gateway, PA | 2019 |
| POINTS KICKING | 8t | Nate Gregg | 11 | Columbus Beechcroft | 2016 |
| POINTS KICKING | 8t | Max Shafer | 11 | Mansfield | 2003 |
| POINTS KICKING | 8t | Steve Schott | 11 | H.D. Woodson | 2006 |
| POINTS KICKING | 8t | Alex Bauer | 11 | Wadsworth | 2018 |
| POINTS KICKING | 8t | Alex Bauer | 11 | Lakewood St. Edward | 2020 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | PUNT YARDS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PUNT YARDS | 1 | Luke Shilling | 373 | Walsh Jesuit | 1998 |
| PUNT YARDS | 2 | Luke Shilling | 363 | Clovis West, CA | 1998 |
| PUNT YARDS | 3 | Luke Shilling | 360 | Glen Mills, PA | 1998 |
| PUNT YARDS | 4 | Rick Maxhimer | 330 | Steubenville | 1969 |
| PUNT YARDS | 5 | Michael Clark | 297 | North Canton | 2008 |
| PUNT YARDS | 6 | Scott Byelene | 294 | Akron North | 1984 |
| PUNT YARDS | 7 | Andrew David | 293 | Medina Highland | 2013 |
| PUNT YARDS | 8 | Steve Schott | 287 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2007 |
| PUNT YARDS | 9 | Robb Maylor | 282 | Canton McKinley | 2006 |
| PUNT YARDS | 10 | Magnus Haines | 271 | Akron St. Vincent | 2017 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | PUNT ATTEMPTS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 1 | Luke Shilling | 10 | Glen Mills, PA | 1998 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 2t | Luke Shilling | 9 | Clovis West, CA | 1998 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 2t | Luke Shilling | 9 | Walsh Jesuit | 1998 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 2t | Robb Maylor | 9 | Canton McKinley | 2006 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Jim Krenzer | 8 | Steubenville | 1966 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Rick Maxhimer | 8 | Steubenville | 1969 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Scott Bylene | 8 | Akron North | 1984 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Andrew David | 8 | Medina Highland | 2013 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Andrew David | 8 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2014 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Michael Clark | 8 | North Canton | 2008 |
| PUNT ATTEMPTS | 5t | Magnus Haines | 8 | Akron St. Vincent | 2017 |
| | | | | |
| (MIN. 3 ATTEMPTS) | RANK | PLAYER | AVE. YARDS PER PUNT | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 1 | Andrew David | 50 | Warren Harding | 2014 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 2 | Shawn Weisend | 48.2 | Cincinnati Elder | 2005 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 3 | Magnus Haines | 47.7 | Cincinnati LaSalle | 2019 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 4t | Magnus Haines | 46 | Gateway, PA | 2019 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 4t | Magnus Haines | 46 | Cincinnati LaSalle | 2020 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 6 | Andrew David | 45.5 | Canton McKinley | 2014 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 7 | Shane Rue | 45.3 | Wooster | 2021 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 8t | Magnus Haines | 44.8 | Akron Hoban | 2019 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 8t | Magnus Haines | 44.8 | Akron Hoban | 2020 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT | 10 | Max Shafer | 44.2 | Cleveland Benedictine | 2003 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | LONGEST PUNT | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| LONGEST PUNT | 1 | Art McConnel | 81 | Warren Harding | 1925 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 2 | Smith | 80 | Akron East | 1925 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 3 | Bob Graber | 72 | Alliance | 1942 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 4t | Shawn Weisend | 70 | Cincinnati Elder | 2005 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 4t | Tim Manion | 70 | Cincinnati Moeller | 1981 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 4t | P. Smith | 70 | Warren Harding | 1924 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 7t | Charley Anderson | 68 | New Castle, PA | 1936 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 7t | Glenn Keller | 68 | Canton Timken | 1944 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 9 | Eric Lightfoot | 66 | Lima Senior | 1996 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 10t | Horace Gillom | 65 | Canton McKinley | 1940 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 10t | Dave Eberhart | 65 | Canton McKinley | 1980 |
| LONGEST PUNT | 10t | Matt Martin | 65 | Massillon Perry | 2002 |