| 2017 | Austin Kutscher | Ohio State | Wide Receiver |
| 2016 | Vincent McConnell | Cincinnati | Offensive Lineman |
| 2016 | Chris Anthony | Eastern Kentucky | Offensive Lineman |
| 2016 | Malcolm Robinson | Minnesota | Defensive Lineman |
| 2016 | Thayer Munford | Ohio State | Offensive Lineman |
| 2014 | John Henry Bronczek | Kent State | Defensive Back |
| 2014 | Andrew David | Michigan / Texas Christian | Placekicker |
| 2013 | Reggie Rogers | Marshall | Wide Receiver |
| 2013 | Nathaniel Devers | Marshall | Offensive Lineman |
| 2013 | Marcus Whitfield | Toledo | Wide Receiver |
| 2012 | Kentrell Taylor | Kent State | Linebacker |
| 2012 | Gareon Conley | Ohio State | Cornerback |
| 2012 | Kyle Kempt | Oregon State / Iowa State | Quarterback |
| 2010 | Devin Smith | Ohio State | Wide Receiver |
| 2010 | Justin Olack | Toledo | Wide Receiver |
| 2009 | Robert Partridge | MIami of Ohio | Quarterback |
| 2009 | Jeff Myers | Toledo | Offensive Lineman |
| 2007 | Devoe Torrence | Akron | Running Back |
| 2007 | Steve Schott | Ball State | Placekicker |
| 2006 | Brian Gamble | Illinois | Wide Receiver |
| 2006 | Andrew Dailey | Penn State | Linebacker |
| 2005 | Brett Huffman | Duke | Tight End |
| 2005 | Antonio James | Illinois | Defensive Lineman |
| 2003 | Billy Relford | Toledo | Cornerback |
| 2002 | Shawn Crable | Michigan | Linebacker |
| 2002 | Devin Jordan | Ohio State | Wide Receiver |
| 2002 | J. P. Simon | Cincinnati | Offensive LIne |
| 2001 | Andy Alleman | Akron | Offensive Lineman |
| 2001 | Justin Zwick | Ohio State | Quarterback |
| 2001 | David Abdul | Pittsburgh | Placekicker |
| 2000 | Matt Shem | Northern Michigan | |
| 1999 | Jesse Scott | Akron | Running Back |
| 1999 | Jeremiah Drobney | Kentucky | Tight End |
| 1999 | Ellery Moore | Kentucky | Defensive Lineman |
| 1999 | Greg Dickerhoof | Villanova | |
| 1998 | Luke Shilling | Akron | |
| 1998 | Neil Buckosh | Kent State | |
| 1997 | Christian Morgan | Akron | Running Back |
| 1996 | Paul Salvino | Akron | |
| 1996 | Ben Mast | Michigan | Offensive Lineman |
| 1994 | Willie Spencer, Jr. | Akron | Quarterback |
| 1993 | Chad Buckland | Purdue | |
| 1992 | Brandon Jackson | Kentucky | Offensive LIneman |
| 1992 | Dan Hackenbracht | Michigan State | Defensive Back |
| 1991 | Jason Woullard | Bowling Green | Linebacker |
| 1991 | Travis McGuire | Ohio State | Running Back |
| 1991 | Falondo Ashcraft | Miami of Ohio | |
| 1989 | Lee Hurst | Kent State | Placekicker |
| 1989 | Tom Manion | US Air Force Academy | |
| 1989 | Ray Kovasciss | Vanderbilt | |
| 1989 | Rameir Martin | Bowling Green | Wide Receiver |
| 1988 | Darren Longshore | Iowa State | |
| 1988 | Trace Liggett | Kansas | |
| 1988 | Bob Dunwiddie | Pittsburgh | |
| 1988 | Jason Stafford | Youngstown | |
| 1987 | Eric White | Bowling Green | Quarterback |
| 1987 | John Woodlock | Michigan | |
| 1987 | John Schilling | Ohio State | |
| 1987 | James Bullock | North Carolina State | |
| 1986 | Jerrod Vance | Penn State | Linebacker |
| 1986 | Ken Hawkins | Syracuse | |
| 1985 | Wes Siegenthaler | Ohio State | |
| 1984 | John Kroah | | |
| 1983 | Brian DeWitz | Indiana | Quarterback |
| 1983 | Craig Johnson | Michigan State | Running Back |
| 1983 | Chris Spielman | Ohio State | Linebacker |
| 1983 | Tom Gruno | Toledo | |
| 1982 | Jim Bushe | US Air Force Academy | |
| 1982 | Jim Bushe | US Air Force Academy | |
| 1981 | Tim Manion | Georgia Tech | Tight End |
| 1981 | Rick Spielman | Southern Illinois | Linebacker |
| 1981 | George Nikitenko | Toledo | |
| 1979 | Bill Scott | Indiana | |
| 1978 | Eric Barnard | Ohio State | |
| 1978 | Brent Offenbecher | Wake Forest / Ohio State | Quarterback |
| 1978 | Curtis Strawder | | Wide Receiver |
| 1977 | Kurt Walterhouse | Cornell | |
| 1977 | Tim Daniels | Tennessee | Offensive LIne |
| 1974 | Mark Streeter | Arizona | |
| 1974 | Joe Studer | Bowling Green | Offensive LIneman |
| 1974 | Tim Gutshall | Iowa | Linebacker |
| 1973 | Charles Danzy | Iowa | |
| 1972 | Kevin Westover | Indiana | Tight End |
| 1972 | Alex Wood | Iowa | |
| 1972 | Tom Hannon | Michigan State | Defensive Back |
| 1972 | Donnie Muhlbach | Syracuse | |
| 1971 | Steve Studer | Bowling Green | Offensive Lineman |
| 1971 | Art Thompson | Bowling Green | |
| 1970 | Larry Harper | Miami of Ohio | Wide Receiver |
| 1970 | Dennis Franklin | Michigan | Quarterback |
| 1970 | Steve Luke | Ohio State | Defensive Back |
| 1970 | Mike Mauger | Wisconson / Kent State | Running Back |
| 1970 | Tim Ridgley | Wyoming | Offensive Lineman |
| 1969 | Bill Dorman | Georgia Tech | Offensive LIneman |
| 1969 | Pat Midgley | Ohio University | LInebacker |
| 1968 | George Whitfield, Sr. | Wichita State | |
| 1968 | Rovertus "Burt" Dampier | Ohio University | |
| 1967 | Tom Houser | Ohio State | Tight End |
| 1966 | Will Foster | Eastern Michigan | Defensive End |
| 1966 | Tom James, Jr. | Kent State | |
| 1966 | John Muhlbach | Ohio State | |
| 1966 | Mike Sherret | Xavier | |
| 1965 | Dave Sheegog | Kent State | Quarterback |
| 1965 | Paul Marks | Memphis | |
| 1965 | Dave Whitfield | Ohio State | |
| 1965 | Terry Manson | US Naval Academy | |
| 1965 | Dick Hartley | Rutgers | Offensive LIne |
| 1963 | Bill Blunt | Kent State | |
| 1963 | Will Perry | Kent State | |
| 1963 | Ron Swartz | Kent State | |
| 1963 | Steve Tarle | Kent State | |
| 1963 | Graydon Eckard | Kent State | |
| 1961 | Ken Ivan | Notre Dame | |
| 1961 | Charlie Brown | Syracuse | |
| 1961 | Bob Baker | Ohio University | |
| 1960 | George Demis | Alabama | |
| 1960 | Dave Null | Wyoming | |
| 1959 | Hase McKey | Arizona State | |
| 1959 | Jack Oliver | Columbia | |
| 1959 | Joe Sparma | Ohio State | |
| 1959 | Mike Hershberger | Cincinnati | |
| 1958 | Bob Vogel | Ohio State | Offensive Lineman |
| 1958 | Jerry Allen | Omaha | |
| 1955 | David Canary | Cincinnati | |
| 1955 | Jim Houston | Ohio State | |
| 1955 | Jim Schumacher | Ohio State | |
| 1954 | Homer Floyd | Kansas | Running Back |
| 1954 | Ray Francisco | Kansas | |
| 1953 | Jim Letcavits | Kansas | |
| 1953 | Bruce Schram | Ohio State | |
| 1952 | Jim Geiser | Ohio State | |
| 1952 | Bob Khoenle | Purdue | |
| 1951 | Paul Francisco | Kansas | |
| 1951 | Bob Grier | Pittsburgh | |
| 1950 | Jim Reichenbach | Ohio State | |
| 1949 | Don James | Miami | |
| 1948 | John McVay | Miami of Ohio | |
| 1948 | Mike Takac | Ohio State | |
| 1948 | Jack "Bunker" Hill | Cincinnati | |
| 1943 | Bob Williams | US Air Force Academy | |
| 1940 | Horace Gillom | Nevada | Wide Receiver |
| 1940 | Gordon Appleby | Ohio State | |
| 1940 | Tom James | Ohio State | |
| 1940 | Nehri Buggs | South Carolina State | |
| 1939 | Stanfield Wells | Michigan | |
| 1938 | Lin Houston | Ohio State? | |
| 1937 | Don Snavely | Columbia | |
| 1937 | Bob Glass | Tulane | Running Back |
| 1936 | Mike Byelene | Purdue | |
| 1935 | Augie Morningstar | Purdue | |
| 1935 | Ed Molinski | Tennessee | |
| 1932 | Mel Knowlton | MIami of Ohio | Quarterback |
| 1922 | Edwin "Dutch" Hill | Columbia | Running Back |
| 1919 | Harry Stuhldreher | Notre Dame | Quarterback |
| 1911 | Fred Heyman | Washington & Jefferson | |
| Ben Roderick Jr. | Vanderbilt | |
| Ben Roderick Sr. | Boston College & Columbia | |
| Bernard Sullivan | Bowling Green | |
| | Bill Morrow | Colgate | |
| Bill Zorn | Michigan State | |
| Charlie Anderson | Ohio State | |
| Dave Geshwind | Northeastern | |
| Dave Kulick | Bowling Green | Offensive Lineman |
| Dick Lutz | Akron | |
| Fred Schram | Ohio State | |
| George Sluser | Ohio State | |
| Lee "Junie" Anderson | Dartmouth | |
| Mike Autry | Iowa & Kent State | |
| Rob Stephan | Bowling Green | |
| Ron Williams | Columbia | |
| Todd Schumacher | Iowa | |
