| Rushing | Yards | 1 | Travis McGuire | 1991 | 302 |
| Rushing | Yards | 2 | Jamir Thomas | 2018 | 269 |
| Rushing | Yards | 3 | Homer Floyd | 1954 | 263 |
| - | | | | | |
| Rushing | Attempts | 1 | Jamir Thomas | 2017 | 42 |
| Rushing | Attempts | 2 | Elwood Kammer | 1925 | 39 |
| Rushing | Attempts | 3 | Ryne Moore | 2012 | 37 |
| - | | | | | |
| Rushing | Touchdowns | 1 | Travis McGuire | 1991 | 5 |
| Rushing | Touchdowns | 2t | Art Hastings | 1960 | 4 |
| Rushing | Touchdowns | 2t | JD Crabtree | 2014 | 4 |
| - | | | | | |
| Rushing | Longest TD Run | 1 | Homer Floyd | 1953 | 80 |
| Rushing | Longest TD Run | 2 | Travis McGuire | 1991 | 79 |
| Rushing | Longest TD Run | 3 | Jamir Thomas | 2018 | 78 |
| - | | | | | |
| Passing | Yards | 1 | Kyle Kempt | 2012 | 285 |
| Passing | Yards | 2 | Mike Scott | 1984 | 244 |
| Passing | Yards | 3 | Robert Partridge | 2009 | 236 |
| - | | | | | |
| Passing | Attempts | 1 | Mike Scott | 1984 | 48 |
| Passing | Attempts | 2 | Kyle Kempt | 2010 | 35 |
| Passing | Attempts | 3 | Robert Partridge | 2009 | 34 |
| - | | | | | |
| Passing | Completions | 1 | Justin Zwick | 2001 | 24 |
| Passing | Completions | 2 | Mike Scott | 1984 | 23 |
| Passing | Completions | 3 | Aidan Longwell | 2019 | 17 |
| - | | | | | |
| Passing | Touchdowns | 1t | Rich Crescenze | 1953 | 3 |
| Passing | Touchdowns | 1t | Dave Irwin | 1999 | 3 |
| Passing | Touchdowns | 1t | Kyle Kempt | 2012 | 3 |
| - | | | | | |
| Passing | Longest TD Pass | 1 | Aidan Longwell | 2019 | 79 |
| Passing | Longest TD Pass | 2 | Kyle Kempt | 2012 | 66 |
| Passing | Longest TD Pass | 3 | Ron Swartz | 1963 | 65 |
| - | | | | | |
| Receiving | Yards | 1 | Devin Jordan | 2001 | 154 |
| Receiving | Yards | 2 | Devin Smith | 2010 | 135 |
| Receiving | Yards | 3 | Jayden Ballard | 2019 | 114 |
| - | | | | | |
| Receiving | Receptions | 1 | Bruce Spicer | 1984 | 11 |
| Receiving | Receptions | 2 | Devin Jordan | 2001 | 10 |
| Receiving | Receptions | 3 | Jayden Ballard | 2019 | 9 |
| - | | | | | |
| Receiving | Touchdowns | 1t | Curt Strawder | 1978 | 2 |
| Receiving | Touchdowns | 1t | Austin Jasinski | 2016 | 2 |
| Receiving | Touchdowns | 1t | Jayden Ballard | 2019 | 2 |
| - | | | | | |
| Receiving | Longest TD Reception | 1 | Jayden Ballard | 2019 | 79 |
| Receiving | Longest TD Reception | 2 | Gareon Conley | 2012 | 66 |
| Receiving | Longest TD Reception | 3 | Bill Blunt | 1963 | 65 |
| - | | | | | |
| Scoring | Points | 1 | Travis McGuire | 1991 | 30 |
| Scoring | Points | 2 | JD Crabtree | 2014 | 24 |
| Scoring | Points | 3 | Jake Reinman | 2009 | 18 |
| - | | | | | |
| Kicking | Longest Field Goal | 1 | Steve Schott | 2006 | 47 |
| Kicking | Longest Field Goal | 2 | Steve Schott | 2007 | 41 |
| Kicking | Longest Field Goal | 3t | Andrew David | 2013 | 35 |
| Kicking | Longest Field Goal | 3t | Alex Bauer | 2019 | 35 |
| - | | | | | |
| Kicking | Scoring | 1 | Andrew David | 2012 | 13 |
| Kicking | Scoring | 2 | Andrew David | 2013 | 9 |
| Kicking | Scoring | 3 | Brett Marshall | 1998 | 8 |
| - | | | | | |
| Kicking | Longest Punt | 1 | Austin Jasinski | 2016 | 65 |
| Kicking | Longest Punt | 2 | Andrew David | 2014 | 52 |
| Kicking | Longest Punt | 3 | Magnus Haines | 2017 | 43 |
| - | | | | | |
| Returns | Longest Punt Rtn TD | 1 | (none) | | |
| - | | | | | |
| Returns | Longest Kickoff Rtn TD | 1 | Keyshawn Watson | 1996 | 96 |
| Returns | Longest Kickoff Rtn TD | 2 | Larry Harper | 1991 | 94 |
| Returns | Longest Kickoff Rtn TD | 3 | Mark McDew | 1967 | 91 |
| - | | | | | |
| Returns | Longest Interception Rtn TD | 1 | Darius Edwards | 1971 | 76 |
| Returns | Longest Interception Rtn TD | 2 | Elwood Kammer | 1924 | 65 |
| Returns | Longest Interception Rtn TD | 3 | Dick Arrington | 1943 | 64 |
| - | | | | | |
| Defense | Tackle Points | 1t | Stephan Laury | 2011 | 11.0 |
| Defense | Tackle Points | 1t | Jamir Thomas | 2015 | 11.0 |
| Defense | Tackle Points | 3t | Dillon Cowan | 2012 | 10.5 |
| Defense | Tackle Points | 3t | JD Crabtree | 2012 | 10.5 |