| YEAR | OPPONENT | SCORE | OTs | RESULT | SEASON | THE WINNING PLAY |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1988 | Canton McKinley | 10 - 7 | 1 | W | 7 - 3 | Lee Hurst 23 yd. field goal |
| 1989 | Akron St. Vincent | 28 - 21 | 1 | W | 10 - 3 | Lee Hurst 4 yd. run |
| 1994 | Canton McKinley | 42 - 41 | 1 | W | 10 - 2 | Victor Redrick 16-yd. run; Nick Pribich PAT |
| 2002 | Warren Harding ** | 20 - 21 | 1 | L | 11 - 3 | Missed extra point |
| 2007 | Canton McKinley | 23 - 20 | 1 | W | 6 - 4 | Chris Willoughby 1 yd. run |
| 2013 | Canton GlenOak | 23 - 20 | 2 | W | 9 - 3 | Andrew David 20 yd. field goal |