| RANK | RECORD | OPPONENT | YEAR | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RANK | POINTS | OPPONENT | YEAR | ||
| POINTS | 1 | 101 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 | |
| POINTS | 2 | 94 | Akron North | 1922 | |
| POINTS | 3 | 90 | Barberton | 1959 | |
| POINTS | 4t | 82 | Uhrichsville | 1918 | |
| POINTS | 4t | 82 | Salem | 1923 | |
| POINTS | 6t | 77 | St. John's Collegiate, ON | 2014 | |
| POINTS | 6t | 77 | Alliance | 1924 | |
| POINTS | 8t | 76 | Youngstown East | 1991 | |
| POINTS | 8t | 76 | Fremont Ross | 2002 | |
| POINTS | 8t | 76 | Columbus Independence | 2021 | |
| RANK | TOUCHDOWNS | OPPONENT | YEAR | ||
| TOUCHDOWNS | 1 | 15 | Akron North | 1922 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 2 | 14 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 3 | 13 | Urichsville | 1918 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 4t | 12 | Salem | 1923 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 4t | 12 | Barberton | 1959 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Alliance | 1924 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Akron East | 1935 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Portsmouth | 1936 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Mansfield | 1939 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Youngstown East | 1991 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Cordoza, DC | 1997 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Fremont Ross | 2002 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Youngstown Woodrow Wilson | 2002 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Toledo Bowsher | 2016 | |
| TOUCHDOWNS | 6t | 11 | Columbus Independence | 2021 |