| RANK | PUNT RETURN YARDS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 1 | 164 | Canton GlenOak | 2021 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 2 | 130 | Wooster | 2021 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 3t | 124 | Alliance | 1963 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 3t | 124 | Parma Normandy | 2008 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 3t | 124 | Warren Harding | 2020 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 6 | 122 | Akron Firestone | 2019 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 7 | 112 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2015 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 8 | 105 | Struthers | 1963 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 9 | 103 | Mentor | 2010 |
| PUNT RETURN YARDS | 10 | 101 | Perry | 2020 |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| RANK | PUNT RETURNS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PUNT RETURNS | 1 | 9 | Warren Harding | 2020 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 2t | 7 | Solon | 2007 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 2t | 7 | Canton GlenOak | 2021 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 4t | 6 | Akron Garfield | 1958 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 4t | 6 | Akron Garfield | 2002 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 4t | 6 | Cleveland Benedictine | 2004 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Mansfield | 2002 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Cleveland Benedictine | 2003 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Findlay | 2003 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Cincinnati Western Hills | 2007 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Akron Firestone | 2009 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Mentor | 2010 |
| PUNT RETURNS | 7t | 5 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2015 |
| | | | |
| RANK | AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 1 | 41.3 | Parma Normandy | 2008 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 2 | 40.7 | Akron Firestone | 2019 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 3 | 33.7 | Massillon Perry | 2020 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 4 | 32.5 | Wooster | 2021 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 5 | 31.7 | Steubenville | 2012 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 6 | 29.5 | Sun Valley | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 7 | 29.3 | Columbus Independence | 2021 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 8t | 26.7 | Warren Harding | 2008 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 8t | 26.7 | Brantford, ON | 2008 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER PUNT RETURN | 10 | 24.7 | Austintown Fitch | 2015 |
| | | | |
| RANK | KICK RETURN YARDS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 1 | 275 | Canton McKinley | 2015 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 2 | 189 | Massillon Perry | 2015 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 3 | 172 | Warren Harding | 2015 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 4 | 164 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 2015 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 5 | 154 | Canton McKinley | 2005 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 6t | 151 | Canton McKinley | 2009 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 6t | 151 | Warren Harding | 2021 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 8 | 149 | Cincinnati Moeller | 2022 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 9 | 147 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2008 |
| KICK RETURN YARDS | 10 | 142 | Canton GlenOak | 2012 |
| | | | |
| RANK | KICK RETURNS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| KICK RETURNS | 1t | 9 | Perrysburg | 2014 |
| KICK RETURNS | 1t | 9 | Mentor | 2016 |
| KICK RETURNS | 3 | 8 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 2015 |
| KICK RETURNS | 4t | 7 | Dayton Chaminade | 2003 |
| KICK RETURNS | 4t | 7 | Canton McKinley | 2010 |
| KICK RETURNS | 4t | 7 | Toledo Whitmer | 2012 |
| KICK RETURNS | 4t | 7 | Massillon Perry | 2015 |
| KICK RETURNS | 4t | 7 | Warren Harding | 2015 |
| KICK RETURNS | 9t | 6 | (several) | |
| | | | |
| RANK | AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 1 | 62 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 2 | 56.5 | Akron St. Vincent | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 3 | 55 | Canton McKinley | 2015 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 4 | 51 | Cincinnati Anderson | 2023 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 5 | 42 | Wadsworth | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 6t | 38.5 | Parma Normandy | 2007 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 6t | 38.5 | St. John's Collegiate, ON | 2014 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 8 | 36 | Solon | 2007 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 9t | 34.3 | Akron Buchtel | 2007 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER KICK RETURN | 9t | 34.3 | Reynoldsburg | 2021 |
| | | | |
| RANK | INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 1 | 166 | North Canton | 2002 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 2 | 119 | Massillon Perry | 2012 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 3 | 115 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2002 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 4 | 110 | Brantford, ON | 2008 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 5 | 100 | Barberton | 1954 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 6 | 99 | Cleveland Benedictine | 2020 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 7 | 96 | Toledo Bowsher | 2016 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 8 | 95 | Mentor Lake Catholic | 2013 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 9 | 93 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 2012 |
| INTERCEPTION RETURN YARDS | 10 | 92 | Cincinnati Elder | 2005 |
| | | | |
| RANK | INTERCEPTIONS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 1 | 7 | North Canton | 2002 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 2 | 6 | Cincinnati Elder | 2005 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3t | 4 | Canton McKinley | 2002 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3t | 4 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2002 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3t | 4 | Brantford, ON | 2008 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3t | 4 | Toledo Bowsher | 2015 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3t | 4 | Toledo Bowsher | 2016 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 8 | 3 | (several) | |
| | | | |
| (MINIMUM 2 INTERCEPTIONS) | RANK | AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 1 | 46.5 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 2012 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 2 | 44.5 | Akron Buchtel | 2003 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 3 | 40.5 | Columbus Walnut Ridge | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 4 | 39.7 | Massillon Perry | 2012 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 5 | 39 | Canton GlenOak | 2009 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 6t | 37 | Pauline Johnson, ON | 2012 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 6t | 37 | Sun Valley, PA | 2018 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 8 | 33 | Cleveland Benedictine | 2020 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 9 | 31.7 | Mentor Lake Catholic | 2013 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 10t | 31 | North Park, ON | 2006 |
| AVERAGE YARDS PER INTERCEPTION RETURN | 10t | 31 | Columbus Bishop Sycamore | 2020 |