| RANK | PLAYER | YARDS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| YARDS | 1 | Justin Zwick | 407 | Dayton Chaminade | 2001 |
| YARDS | 2 | Justin Zwick | 402 | Lima Senior | 2000 |
| YARDS | 3 | Justin Zwick | 375 | Akron Garfield | 2000 |
| YARDS | 4 | Justin Zwick | 360 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2000 |
| YARDS | 5 | Danny Clark | 358 | Austintown Fitch | 2013 |
| YARDS | 6 | Da'One Owens | 341 | Grove City Central Crossing | 2023 |
| YARDS | 7 | Aidan Longwell | 337 | Massillon Perry | 2019 |
| YARDS | 8 | Brody Tonn | 330 | Canton GlenOak | 2010 |
| YARDS | 9 | Kyle Kempt | 327 | Canton GlenOak | 2012 |
| YARDS | 10 | Aidan Longwell | 324 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2017 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | ATTEMPTS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| ATTEMPTS | 1 | Justin Zwick | 60 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2000 |
| ATTEMPTS | 2 | Mike Scott | 48 | Canton McKinley | 1984 |
| ATTEMPTS | 3 | Seth Blankenship | 46 | Akron St. Vincent | 2015 |
| ATTEMPTS | 4 | Seth Blankenship | 45 | Mentor | 2016 |
| ATTEMPTS | 5 | Justin Zwick | 43 | Akron Garfield | 2000 |
| ATTEMPTS | 6t | Quentin Paulik | 42 | Warren Harding | 2003 |
| ATTEMPTS | 6t | Justin Zwick | 42 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2001 |
| ATTEMPTS | 8 | Kyle Kempt | 41 | Canton GlenOak | 2012 |
| ATTEMPTS | 9 | Justin Zwick | 39 | Dayton Chaminade | 2001 |
| ATTEMPTS | 10t | Justin Zwick | 38 | Massillon Perry | 2000 |
| ATTEMPTS | 10t | Justin Zwick | 38 | North Canton | 2001 |
| ATTEMPTS | 10t | Kyle Kempt | 38 | Warren Harding | 2010 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | COMPLETIONS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| COMPLETIONS | 1t | Kyle Kempt | 29 | Canton GlenOak | 2012 |
| COMPLETIONS | 1t | Justin Zwick | 29 | Akron Garfield | 2000 |
| COMPLETIONS | 3 | Seth Blankenship | 28 | Akron St. Vincent | 2015 |
| COMPLETIONS | 4 | Justin Zwick | 27 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2000 |
| COMPLETIONS | 5t | Justin Zwick | 24 | Canton McKinley | 2001 |
| COMPLETIONS | 5t | Justin Zwick | 24 | Dayton Chaminade | 2001 |
| COMPLETIONS | 5t | Justin Zwick | 24 | Mansfield | 2001 |
| COMPLETIONS | 5t | Steve Hymes | 24 | Mansfield | 2003 |
| COMPLETIONS | 9t | Mike Scott | 23 | Canton McKinley | 1984 |
| COMPLETIONS | 9t | Justin Zwick | 23 | North Canton | 2001 |
| COMPLETIONS | 9t | Quentin Paulik | 23 | Warren Harding | 2003 |
| | | | | |
| (MIN. 10 ATTEMPTS) | RANK | PLAYER | COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 1 | Zach Catrone | 100.0 (10/10) | Massillon Perry | 2020 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 2 | Aidan Longwell | 93.3 (14/15) | Penn Trafford, PA | 2019 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 3 | Matt Martin | 90.0 (9/10) | Youngstown Wilson | 2002 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 4 | Aidan Longwell | 87.0 (20/23) | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | 2019 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 5 | Jalen Slaughter | 86.7 (13/15) | Columbus Independence | 2021 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 6 | Brent Offenbecher | 85.0 (17/20) | Canton McKinley | 1978 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 7t | Lee Hurst | 81.8 (9/11) | Warren Harding | 1989 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 7t | Bobby Huth | 81.8 (9/11) | Canton McKinley | 2005 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 7t | Bobby Huth | 81.8 (9/11) | Chardon | 2005 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 7t | Chris Willoughby | 81.8 (9/11) | Middletown | 2007 |
| COMPLETION PERCENTAGE | 7t | Danny Clark | 81.8 (9/11) | St. John's Collegiate, ON | 2014 |
| | | | | |
| (MIN. 10 ATTEMPTS) | RANK | PLAYER | YARDS PER ATTEMPT | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 1 | Zach Catrone | 23.4 | Massillon Perry | 2020 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 2 | Aidan Longwell | 21 | Louisville | 2018 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 3 | Aidan Longwell | 19.1 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2017 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 4 | Bobby Huth | 17.5 | Chardon | 2005 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 5 | Michael Clark | 16.9 | Jordan, Sandy, UT | 2008 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 6 | Ben Hymes | 16.3 | Akron St. Vincent | 1996 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 7t | Dennis Franklin | 15.6 | Steubenville | 1970 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 7t | Danny Clark | 15.6 | Austintown Fitch | 2013 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 9 | Gary Herring | 15.3 | Hamilton Garfield | 1969 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 10t | Dave Irwin | 15.2 | Austintown Fitch | 1999 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 10t | Greg Wood | 15.2 | Steubenville | 1973 |
| YARDS PER ATTEMPT | 10t | Seth Blankenship | 15.2 | Columbus Beechcroft | 2016 |
| | | | | |
| (MIN. 5 COMPLETIONS) | RANK | PLAYER | YARDS PER COMPLETION | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 1 | Brian DeWitz | 33.2 | Canton GlenOak | 1982 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 2 | Brian DeWitz | 32.8 | Barberton | 1983 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 3 | Aidan Longwell | 31 | Canton GlenOak | 2019 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 4 | Dennis Franklin | 30.4 | Trotwood Madison | 1970 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 5 | Aidan Longwell | 29.5 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2017 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 6 | Seth Blankenship | 29 | Dublin Scioto | 2016 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 7 | Aidan Longwell | 28.9 | Louisville | 2018 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 8 | Gary Herring | 26.1 | Hamilton Garfield | 1969 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 9 | Dave Irwin | 26 | Austintown Fitch | 1999 |
| YARDS PER COMPLETION | 10 | Mike Danzy | 25.8 | Alliance | 1992 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | TOUCHDOWN PASSES | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 1 | Justin Zwick | 6 | Fremont Ross | 2001 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Justin Zwick | 5 | Akron Buchtel | 2000 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Justin Zwick | 5 | Austintown Fitch | 2001 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Justin Zwick | 5 | Mt. Lebanon, PA | 2001 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Matt Martin | 5 | Akron Garfield | 2002 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Robert Partridge | 5 | Warren Harding | 2009 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Kyle Kempt | 5 | Akron Firestone | 2012 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Seth Blankenship | 5 | Columbus Beechcroft | 2016 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Aidan Longwell | 5 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2017 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Aidan Longwell | 5 | Montclair, PA | 2018 |
| TOUCHDOWN PASSES | 2t | Aidan Longwell | 5 | Massillon Perry | 2019 |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | INTERCEPTIONS | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 1 | Brody Tonn | 6 | Akron Buchtel | 2010 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 2 | Quentin Paulik | 5 | Warren Harding | 2003 |
| INTERCEPTIONS | 3 | (several) | 3 | | |
| | | | | |
| RANK | PLAYER | LONGEST COMPLETION | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 1 | Aidan Longwell | 95 | Gateway, PA | 2019 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 2t | Kyle Kempt | 89 | Red Lion Christian Acad, DE | 2022 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 2t | Seth Blankenship | 89 | Dublin Scioto | 2016 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 4 | Danny Clark | 86 | Medina Highland | 2013 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 5t | Robert Partridge | 82 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | 2009 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 5t | Aidan Longwell | 82 | Massillon Perry | 2019 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 7t | Johnny James | 81 | Toledo Waite | 1955 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 7t | Jim Alexander | 81 | Newark | 1961 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 7t | Ron Swartz | 81 | Cleveland Benedictine | 1962 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 7t | Brody Tonn | 81 | Canton GlenOak | 2010 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 11t | Romeo Pellegrini | 80 | Canton Timken | 1943 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 11t | Dennis Franklin | 80 | Akron St. Vincent | 1970 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 11t | George Whitfield | 80 | Mansfield | 1995 |
| LONGEST COMPLETION | 11t | Danny Clark | 80 | Austintown Fitch | 2013 |
| | | | | |
| (MIN. 10 ATTEMPTS) | RANK | PLAYER | PASS EFFICIENCY | OPPONENT | YEAR |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 1 | Zach Catrone | 395 | Massillon Perry | 2022 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 2 | Aidan Longwell | 322 | Youngstown Ursuline | 2017 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 3 | Aidan Longwell | 307 | Penn-Trafford, PA | 2019 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 4 | Seth Blankenship | 301 | Columbus Beechcroft | 2016 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 5 | Matt Martin | 295 | Youngstown Woodrow Wilson | 2002 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 6 | Aidan Longwell | 291 | Louisville | 2018 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 7 | Bobby Huth | 288 | Chardon | 2005 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 8 | Aidan Longwell | 277 | Bedford | 2017 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 9 | Matt Martin | 267 | Akron Garfield | 2002 |
| PASS EFFICIENCY | 10 | Jalen Slaughter | 253 | Cincinnati Moeller | 2022 |