Bulldogs Beat Tigers
13-7 On Breaks
Two High Passes Give Canton 2 Touchdowns
And Likely State Title
By LUTHER EMERY
The Washington high
school Tigers “passed” the state championship eight miles eastward Saturday afternoon
when they handed the Canton McKinley Bulldogs a 13-7 victory before a chilled
crowd of 21,000 fans.
Two high passes from
center that went over the Massillon punter’s head, enabled McKinley to score
its two touchdowns. One was covered in
the end zone, the other only required a three-yard effort to get the score.
The Tigers got their
touchdown the hard way – a 79-yard drive.
They made more first downs, 12-4 and gained twice as many net yards, but
lost the game.
In short, they beat
the Bulldogs everywhere but on the scoreboard.
But it is the score that counts and in years to come, the score, not the
statistics will be remembered.
The Canton victory
narrows Massillon’s edge in the 60-game series to three games. The Tigers have won 29, the Bulldogs 26 and
five have ended in tie scores.
* * *
THE
TRIUMPH brought Canton its first
undefeated season since 1934 when a Bulldog team coached by Jimmy Aiken whipped
Massillon 21-6 to hang up a string of 11 wins for the season which entitled it
to a just claim to the state title.
McKinley was highly
elated over its victory and had every reason to be. It was the first time the Bulldogs had beaten the Tigers since
1947, and the victory will undoubtedly gain them the state title.
The counting of
ballots cast in The Associated Press poll tonight should only be a mere
formality since the game was billed as one in which the state title was to go
to the winner. As a result the Hall of
Fame trophy, which Massillon has won the last seven years, will likely be awarded
to Canton McKinley.
There’s a
possibility a campaign by a couple of other undefeated teams will wrest some
ballots from the Bulldogs.
Two out-of-town
reporters with ballots in their pockets, who had watched the game on the
television screen, indicated to us Sunday they were going to desert the
Bulldogs and cast their votes for one of the other undefeated teams because of
Massillon’s superior showing in statistics.
However, we cannot
see their logic in denying the Bulldogs the title in that none of the other
undefeated teams has played a comparable schedule or has beaten Massillon, the
defending champ.
* * *
WE
SHALL VOTE for Canton, although
we shall do so with tongue in cheek, believing the Tigers are as good if not
the best in the state.
But their 8-1-1
record is against them in the poll. We
don’t know where they will finish in this week’s balloting.
Some writers may
seize the opportunity to knock the local team far down in the ratings,
particularly in view of the clamor for first place.
The Massillon
gridders had nothing to be ashamed of Saturday and that helped to temper the
loss. Our only criticism, and about the
only criticism we heard of Massillon’s play, was a bit of dilly-dallying in the
huddle in the last three minutes of the
game. It took them 35 seconds to get
off next to the last play of the game.
The game, which was
supposed to have been a tremendous offensive contest, actually resolved itself
into more of a defensive game, and the Tigers had nothing to be ashamed of.
They were superior
to McKinley on both offense and defense.
The locals who
rolled to nine first downs the first half only got three the second half, but
still out-gained McKinley in net yardage from running and passing plays the
last two periods, 54 to 52.
*
* *
CANTON
McKINLEY’S vaunted offense,
which had been rolling along at an average of over 400 yards a gained, was held
to a net gain of 62 yards, while the Tigers rolled up 194 net yards rushing and
passing. Deduct 52 yards on two passes
from center that went over the punter’s head and you still have 142 net
yards from scrimmage to the Bulldogs; 69 – and Canton called the game a
defensive victory for the Bulldogs.
Actually the victory
was a gift to McKinley for both touchdowns were donated. No blame should be placed on the centers
responsible for the passes. Both felt
the world had fallen in on them at the end of the contest. It should be pointed out that they were handling
a slippery ball and that a center in modern T football has little opportunity
to actually pass the ball 10 yards or more under game conditions.
They practice it
often but get little actual game experience because the Tigers seldom punt more
than once or twice.
In fact, we saw two
poor center passes, one of which resulted in a blocked kick, in a recent
professional football game.
The breaks just came
at inopportune moments and although the decision of the contest rode on them we
haven’t heard anyone criticize either player.
Furthermore, an
examination of movies of the game failed to substantiate a report that on both
occasions a McKinley player had bumped the ball or put pressure on the
centers. McKinley in no way contributed
to the play.
The first touchdown
was presented in the opening period of play with the Tigers in possession of
the ball on their own 36-yard line, fourth down and nine to go.
Dave Archibald
dropped back to punt and Tom Spicer’s pass from center soared over his
head. Archibald took after the ball and
it rolled to the three-yard line before he could get on it.
* * *
IT
TOOK NAP Barbosa three whacks at
the line to get over but he made it on the third attempt and Nate Harris kicked
the extra point to put McKinley ahead 7-0.
The Tigers tied it up
by taking the kickoff and gallantly marching 79 yards on 18 plays to
score. While doing so they were helped
along by 20 yards in penalties which actually were more than nullified by 25
yards in penalties assessed against them.
Don Duke scored the
T.D. from the two-yard line with eight minutes and 10 seconds remaining in the
second period John Kasunick kicked the extra point a high boot that tied the
score at 7-7.
The Bulldogs got
their second touchdown without effort in the second minute of the fourth
quarter. The Tigers had gotten
themselves into a hole when Ivory Benjamin fumbled a punt and Canton covered it
on the Tigers’ 45.
Dave Archibald got
the ball back for Massillon when he intercepted a Barbosa pass and was downed
on the 20.
* * *
THROWN
BACK a yard by the Bulldgos in
three downs, Archibald again tried to punt.
This time Jim Dowd was centering the ball. His pass, like that of Spicer’s was high and soared over Archibald’s
head and into the end zone. Archibald
dove for the ball and so did two Canton players. Bill White got on it for a touchdown. Harris missed the extra point and that ended the scoring.
Except for the
Tigers’ long touchdown drive, neither team threatened seriously from scrimmage.
The Tigers came
within striking distance on only two other occasions. The first time they got the ball in the second half they worked
to the Bulldog 32-yard line where they surrendered the pigskin to Canton on a
fourth down incompleted pass.
McKinley and
Massillon both got into each other’s territory in the second period.
The advances were
the result of good punt returns.
Benjamin ran brilliantly to the Canton 39 before being knocked out of
bounds but a 15-yard clipping penalty put the ball way back on the Massillon
31, an actual loss of 30 yards and a real blow to the Tigers who were hot at
the moment for it was the first time they had gotten the ball after scoring
their touchdown.
* * *
EVEN
SO they marched with it from
their own 31 back to the Canton 35 where with two yards to go and fourth down
coming up they punted.
Ike Grimsley,
returned brilliantly, lugging the ball back to the Massillon 47. Two five-yard penalties against the Tigers
and a six-yard gain by Don Garman produced a first down on the 31. Barbosa passed seven yards to Jackson, who
fumbled when hit hard by Bob Tracy and Dave Schumacher pounced on the ball for
the Tigers on the 24.
* * *
CANTON
MADE one other effort the last
time it had the ball in the game. The
Bulldogs aided by a 22-yard run by Barbosa, the best Canton gain form
scrimmage, worked the ball into Massillon territory but lost it on downs on the
27.
Charlie Brown, Tiger
safety man, had a possible opportunity to tie the score on this series when he almost
intercepted a pass by Barbosa with what appeared to be a clear field ahead of
him. He juggled the ball while going
full steam ahead and dropped it.
That just about sums
up the offensive maneuvers of the day.
The Tigers succeeded
in stopping the highly vaunted McKinley offense with a special defense cooked
up for the game.
They called it an
eagle defense. The three men in the
center of the five-man defensive line had the responsibility of taking care of
five men in the McKinley line, tackle to tackle. Bob Cocklin, who has been a linebacker, and Jim Houston, who has
been the defensive left end, changed positions. Tracy’s assignment was also switched. The ends and the two wing linebackers had the responsibility of
holding in Bob Williams and Herman Jackson, the Bulldog ends, and they did a
good job of it. McKinley didn’t dare to
try its end around stuff and the ends had difficulty getting downfield for
passes. Only three were attempted. One was intercepted, one was almost
intercepted and the receiver fumbled the only one completed when tackled.
Likewise the three
men in the middle of the line did excellent work. Ken Fisher started on defense as a linebacker for the first time
this season but was knocked out in the second quarter and didn’t play any
longer. He was replaced by Jack Butcher
who played well.
Fisher was taken to
the Massillon city hospital where he has recovered from a slight concussion and
was to be released today.
His experience
undoubtedly was missed by the Tigers offensively in the second half.
* * *
THE
TIGER DEFENSE stopped Ron
Carnahan, the Bulldogs’ leading ground gainer for the season, with a net loss
of nine yards for his ball carrying efforts.
They had all the
other backs bottled up until late in the third period when Barbosa began
running from short punt formation. He
gained 61 of McKinley’s 78 yards rushing.
His longest run of
22 yards was exceeded only by a 26-yard dash reeled off in the first period by
Willie Long in the process of the Tiger’s touchdown drive.
Top ground gainer of
the day, however, was Duke with 66 net yards on 20 carries.
The Bulldogs
actually got off only 21 running plays, three pass plays and three punts from
scrimmage (exclusive of penalty plays) during the game, while the Tigers got
off 54 running, three pass and four punt formation plays.
* * *
CHIEF
REASON for McKinley failing to
get off more plays was inability to move the ball the first half and the Tigers
controlling the ball for 10 minutes and 14 seconds while marching to their only
touchdown.
In that drive they
got the ball through a punt on their own 20.
Brown made two yards and Duke four.
McKinley drew a 15-yard penalty which put the ball on the 41. Brown hit for seven, Duke one and Long
picked up five yards for a first on the Canton 48. Duke made two and James, running on an option, raced 13 yards to
a first on the 33.
The Tigers were
penalized five yards back to the 38 for offside. Long made two yards and the Tigers drew a 15-yard clipping
penalty. A four-yard pass to Brown
gained four yards but another five-yard penalty was slapped on the Tigers for
offside, moving the ball back to midfield.
There Long, running from fullback, sent 26 yards and Archibald in a
two-yard plunge made it a first down on the 22.
Archibald carried
two more times in a row, getting four yards on each try and putting the ball on
the 14. The Tigers drew a five-yard
penalty when Jim Houston jumped offside on the next play, but got it right back
when a delay of game penalty was slapped on McKinley for a substitution.
Duke plunged to a
first on the 11 and James went seven yards to the four.
Duke in two tries
went over for the touchdown, getting two yards each time.
The play on which
James did his running in this series was especially cooked up for the
game. He flared out as though to pass
but had the option of running if the defense dropped back. He gained 56 yards in the game and lost 15
for a net of 41.
The
line-up and summary:
MASSILLON
ENDS – Canary,
Houston, Welcher, Cockling, Nagle.
TACKLES – Graber,
Maier, Whitfield, Schumacher, Hofacre, Allen.
GUARDS – Fisher,
Roan, Ertle, Tracy, Kasunick.
CENTERS – Spicer,
Dowd, Gentzler.
QUARTERBACKS –
James, Brenner.
HALFBACKS – Brown,
Duke, Long, Radtke, Butcher, Benjamin, Washington.
FULLBACKS –
Archibald.
McKINLEY
ENDS – Williams,
Jackson, Jack, Bryant.
TACKLES – Patterson,
Rocknich, Infantides.
GUARDS – Clawson,
Bell, Martin, Bender.
CENTERS – Perdue,
White.
QUARTERBACKS –
Barbosa, Grimsley.
HALFBACKS –
Carnahan, Garman, Phil Martin, Martins, Fontes.
FULLBACKS – Harris.
Score
by quarters:
Massillon 0 7 0 0 7
McKinley 7 0 0 6 13
Touchdowns:
McKinley – Barbosa, White.
Massillon – Duke.
Points
after touchdown:
McKinley – Harris (placekick).
Massillon – Kasunick (placekick).